The Yogurt Shop Murders
Also known as I Can't Believe It's Yogurt murders
Austin · Texas · United States · 1991 · 4 court cases
Every entry in this The Yogurt Shop Murders timeline links its source: court filings, rulings, transcripts and official statements where they're public, and established news reporting where they aren't. The coverage below is hand-picked podcasts, documentaries, books and reporting about this case; we don't link to speculation videos.
Content note — The public record for this case describes violence in specific detail. This case involves an allegation or finding of sexual assault. A victim named in this case was a minor at the time.
Current status
All 3 cleared, 2026
Last update: 19 Feb 2026 →Get an email when something new happens in this case. Updates may be delayed — this is not live court monitoring.
At a glance
- When
6 Dec 1991
- Where
Austin, Texas, United States
- Current status
All 3 cleared, 2026
- Trial verdicts
22 Sep 2002 — Michael Scott found guilty of capital murder · later reversed
30 May 2001 — Springsteen found guilty of capital murder · later reversed
- Sentences
24 Sep 2002 — Michael Scott sentenced to life in prison · later reversed
1 Jun 2001 — Springsteen sentenced to death · later reversed
What happened
On 6 Dec 1991, Austin police saw a fire shortly before midnight at an I Can’t Believe It’s Yogurt!
shop.
Firefighters found Eliza Thomas (17), Jennifer Harbison (17), Sarah Harbison (15) and Amy Ayers (13) inside; Jennifer and Eliza worked there, and Sarah and Amy were there as the shop closed.
The investigation led to arrests and convictions of Michael Scott and Robert Springsteen, but those convictions were overturned and the case ended without a prosecution.
Austin police later linked DNA from the killings to Robert Eugene Brashers, who died in 1999 and was never charged; that is a police finding, not a conviction.
On 19 Feb 2026, a judge declared the four accused men innocent.
Forrest Welborn, a fourth teenager arrested in 1999, was never indicted: two grand juries declined to charge him, and the case against him was dropped in June 2000.
On 19 February 2026 a judge declared all four men actually innocent.
Where it happened
Austin, Texas, United States
Full timeline
Entries linked to a court, prosecutor, police, or government source.
Small dot: EntryOpen ring: MilestoneFilled ring: Verdict
Source clippingView on Newspapers.com Dec 6 · Death reported — investigation event
Four girls murdered; bodies found after yogurt shop fire
Covered in Who Killed These Girls?: Cold Case: The Yogurt Shop Murders
Source clippings · 2View on Newspapers.com Oct 6 · Arrest — court event
Four men arrested in yogurt shop murders
Jun 30 · Court ruling — court event
Charges against Forrest Welborn dismissed
Apr 16 · Trial start — court event
Robert Springsteen's trial begins with jury selection
Springsteen · 2001 criminal caseMay 30 · Verdict — court event
Springsteen found guilty of capital murder
Jun 1 · Sentencing — court event
Springsteen sentenced to death
Scott · 2002 criminal caseJul 29 · Trial start — court event
Michael Scott's trial begins with jury selection
Scott · 2002 criminal caseSep 22 · Verdict — court event
Michael Scott found guilty of capital murder
Scott · 2002 criminal caseSep 24 · Sentencing — court event
Michael Scott sentenced to life in prison
Jan 28 · Court ruling — court event
Charges against Maurice Pierce dismissed; Pierce released
Mar 24 · Appeal — court event
Third Court of Appeals upholds Michael Scott's conviction
Springsteen · 2006 appealMay 24 · Appeal — court event
Court of Criminal Appeals reverses Robert Springsteen’s conviction
- Opinion · Court of Criminal Appeals decision reversing Springsteen's conviction · Texas Court of Criminal Appeals · Court filing · Read court filing ↗
Jun 6 · Appeal — court event
Court of Criminal Appeals reverses Michael Scott's conviction
- Opinion · Court of Criminal Appeals decision reversing Scott's conviction · Texas Court of Criminal Appeals · Court filing · Read court filing ↗
Oct 28 · Court ruling — court event
Judge dismisses all charges against Robert Springsteen and Michael Scott
Dec 23 · Maurice Pierce dies after fleeing a traffic stop — investigation event
Jan 1 · Austin police assign a new cold-case detective to the case — investigation event
Sep 26 · Austin police identify Robert Eugene Brashers as a suspect — investigation event
Covered in The Yogurt Shop Murders and Serial Killer Robert Eugene Brashers: Dr. Colleen Fitzpatrick on Holograms, Hate Mail, and HomicideThe Yogurt Shop Murders and Serial Killer Robert Eugene Brashers: First Person: Dr. Rachel Oefelein of DNA Labs InternationalThe Yogurt Shop Murders: Who Is Robert Eugene Brashers?The Yogurt Shop Murders: The Press Conference on Robert Eugene Brashers
Feb 19 · Exoneration — court event
Judge declares four men innocent in 1991 yogurt shop murders
May 28 · Austin City Council approves $35 million settlement with previously accused men — investigation event
Nov 10 · Exonerated men file a federal lawsuit so a court can approve Austin's $35 million settlement — investigation event
Outside the record
Coverage
8 entries · podcast, book
BOOK Beverly Lowry 2016 Journalistic standpoint
Provides a case-focused account of the 6 Dec 1991 killings and the investigation’s long arc, including the harm caused by the wrongful convictions.
PODCAST1 episode on this case
48 Hours
- 0 of 4 listened
PODCAST1 episode on this case
Cult Liter with Spencer Henry
PODCAST1 episode on this case
Generation Why: True Crime
Austin Yogurt Shop Murders Solved
2 Oct 2025
Court record
4 cases: the 1999 charges proceeded against 4 defendants; the 2002 charges ended in a declaration of innocence; the 2001 charges ended in a declaration of innocence; and the 2006 appeal — Capital murder conviction reversed and sent back to the trial court.
Charges · 19991 case number
- Michael James Scott — Charged · declared innocent, 2026
- Robert Springsteen IV — Charged · declared innocent, 2026
- Maurice Pierce — Charged · declared innocent, 2026 · Deceased
- Forrest Welborn — Never indicted; declared innocent 19 Feb 2026
In the matter of Michael Scott, Robert Springsteen, Maurice Pierce, and Forrest Welborn
Scott · 2002 criminal case2 case numbers
Declared innocent
Conviction reversed; charges later dismissed; declared innocent in 2026
The State of Texas v. Michael Scott
Also filed in this case
Springsteen · 2001 criminal case1 case number
Declared innocent19 Feb 2026
Judge declares four men innocent in 1991 yogurt shop murders
The State of Texas v. Robert Springsteen
Springsteen · 2006 appeal1 case number
Capital murder conviction reversed and sent back to the trial court
Robert Springsteen v. The State of Texas
Also filed in this case
Questions
mooi oooooooo io ioo ooooio oooooooo
oii o ooooio oooo ooooooo oooo oooo oioooooi iooiooioo o moo moo ooooo oooooooi oimoiioo ooioo o oo ooo oooo
io oooooo oiiii io ooioooo
ooi ooo o ooooio oooo ooooooo oooo oii oooo oioooooi oimoiioo ooioo o oo ooo oooo
What was the latest development?
10 Nov 2026: Exonerated men file a federal lawsuit so a court can approve Austin's $35 million settlement. Timeline entry
Follow this case
Get an email when something new happens in this case. Updates may be delayed — this is not live court monitoring.
Know a podcast, documentary, book or magazine about this case?
Record updated 19 Nov 2026
